|
MANAGING
THE COMPLEXITY OF AID FLOW
In recent years, increased
concerns about inappropriate donations of milk as emergency
aid have led IBFAN to a major conclusion: the need for
an integrated approach - including the existence of
appropriate policies and guidelines, coordination, training,
awareness raising among the general public, donors and
the media, infant feeding programmes with a strong monitoring
component and research.
An uncontrolled infant food pipeline
During the Kosovo crisis in 1999,
Marie McGrath (Institute
of Child Health/Save the Children UK) carried out
research on infant feeding in Macedonia. She observed
that :"There was no way of monitoring unsolicited
donations of infant feeding items arriving by road...
Much of the distribution of infant formula was untargeted,
uncoordinated and unmonitored."
FOR
EXAMPLE
|
Unsolicited
Donations
|
A
significant proportion of the aid that arrived in
Macedonia was unsolicited. NATO countries provided
planes which worked on a load up and go
policy with little documentation other than tonnage.
A large proportion of unsolicited donations also
arrived by road. |
|
Untargeted
Distribution
|
Convoys
of trucks containing humanitarian aid arrived and
drove directly to the camps where items were distributed
without a record being kept. The amount of infant
formula distributed appeared to depend on the quantities
in stock rather than on any estimated need. |
|
Uncoordinated
Actions
|
In
spite of a UN early assessment in April 1999 which
identified the lack of promotion and/or protection
of breastfeeding and possible problems regarding
the use of breastmilk substitutes in absence of
education and information, no coordinated approach
to address the issues was established in the field.
It was only after the arrival of a United Nations
High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) nutritionist
in June 1999 that a significant improvement in coordination
and monitoring of infant feeding programmes was
noted. |
|
Unmonitored
Products
|
No
system of monitoring ensured that the World Food
Programme (WFP) guidelines advising against the
general distribution of dried milk powder were respected. |
Source :
"Meeting the nutritional needs of infants during
emergencies: recent experiences and dilemmas",
M. McGrath, A.Seal, A.Taylor, L. Gostelow, Report of
an international workshop, Institute of Child Health,
London, November 1999. Save the Children, UK.
|
Policies
and Guidelines DO Exist
Even
if there is to date no single common UN policy
on infant feeding in emergencies, there is substantial
consensus on the need to protect breastfeeding
in emergencies. Some of the basic documents
to guide policy makers, programme managers and
field workers are:
-
Infant and Young Child
Feeding in Emergencies, operational guidance
for emergency and relief staff and policy-makers.
Document prepared by the inter-agency working
group on infant feeding in emergencies and
supported by a number of key relief organisations,
2001. Request a copy from Fiona OReilly,
Emergency Nutrition Network: foreilly@tcd.ie.
-
Infant Feeding in
Emergencies. Policy, Strategy and Practice.
Report of the Ad Hoc Group on Infant Feeding
in Emergencies. May 1999. ENN, Emergency
Nutrition Network: http://www.ennonline.net
(Printed
version available in Baby Milk Action's
Virtual
Shop).
-
Policy of the UNHCR
related to the Acceptance, Distribution
and Use of Milk Products in Feeding Programs
in Refugee Settings. UNHCR, 1989.
-
The International
Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes
and relevant WHA Resolutions.(Printed
version available in Baby Milk Action's
Virtual
Shop).
-
Protecting Infant
Health. A
Health Workers Guide to the International
Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes.
9th Edition, IBFAN Penang, April 1999.
(Printed
version available in Baby Milk Action's
Virtual
Shop).
-
Guiding Principles
on Feeding Infants and Young Children during
Emergencies.
WHO Nutrition. Annex to: The Management
of Nutrition in Emergencies, WHO, 2000.
-
The SPHERE project.
Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards
in Disaster Response.
1st edition. 1998. http://www.sphereproject.org/
-
Feeding in emergencies
for Infants under six months Practical Guidelines.
OXFAM. Carter K. / OXFAM Public Health Team,
1996.
|
|